Led by "All I Want"—a post-hardcore pep talk with a skyscraping chorus—What Separates Me from You largely trades in A Day to Remember's gruff metalcore edges for irresistible catchiness. The sugary pop-punk earworms "It's Complicated" and "Better Off This Way" (the latter of which boasts a full-on "whoa-oh-oh" sing-along) are mid-'00s emo classics, while "Out of Time" turns its punky sneer into a cheerleader-worthy chant. Even the cathartic screamo of "You Be Tails, I'll Be Sonic" bears a gorgeous, melodic sheen.