Matthew Gumley

- In the Way
- Elf: The Musical (Original Broadway Cast Recording) · 2011
- I'll Believe in You
- Elf: The Musical (Original Broadway Cast Recording) · 2011
- There Is a Santa Claus
- Elf: The Musical (Original Broadway Cast Recording) · 2011
- A Christmas Song (Reprise)
- Elf: The Musical (Original Broadway Cast Recording) · 2011
- The Story of Buddy the Elf
- Elf: The Musical (Original Broadway Cast Recording) · 2011
- Getting Married Today (Live)
- When I Grow Up: Broadway's Next Generation - Live at 54 Below · 2013
- Someone to Fall Back On (Live)
- When I Grow Up: Broadway's Next Generation - Live at 54 Below · 2013
- Agony (Reprise) [Live]
- When I Grow Up: Broadway's Next Generation - Live at 54 Below · 2013
- Agony (Live)
- When I Grow Up: Broadway's Next Generation - Live at 54 Below · 2013

Top Songs