Darren Criss commanded the spotlight when he appeared on Glee in the early 2010s. After the show wrapped, he further flaunted his versatility on Broadway and on television. His willingness to take on seemingly any challenge—as well as his velvet-lined voice and ability to command intimacy—has made him an excellent off-screen pop star as well, whether he's covering Dave Matthews Band smashes alongside superstar DJ Steve Aoki, crooning love songs like "I Don't Mind" over tinkling pianos and swooping strings, or performing revved-up pop-rock with his brother, Chuck, in their duo Computer Games.