8 Songs, 53 Minutes


Ratings and Reviews

4.8 out of 5
95 Ratings

95 Ratings

Gandalf Stormcrow ,

Quintessential music comes to life

This album is timeless, and this remake is outstanding. More subtleties of these talented geniuses come to light in this epic that should be counted in the greatest albums of all time. This is perhaps the last collective work of the Genesis members before they began to seek their individual paths, and accordingly it brings all of their extraordinary musicianship together!

Memoir ,

A beauty of an album

Gabriel-era Genesis... oh, the nostalgia. If there's a cultural zenith that reaches beyond recordings like this, then I've yet to find it. Nothing, and absolutely nothing entertains quite like Gabriel and company did on these earlier forays into their undeniably unique sound. Tighter musically after several albums under their belt, Genesis is able to do here what some groups struggle an entire career to produce consistently: a polished prog rock approach, with a sincerity and origianlity that make the listener feel..."comfortable" is really the best way to describe it. Each track generates a specific feeling within the observer, a great example being the classic "Firth of Fifth". Also contained here is the delightful "I Know Wht I Like (In Your Wardrobe)", arguably one of the most "fun" early Genesis tracks. A great album with the ranks of "Nursery Cryme" and "Foxtrot", "Selling England by the Pound" is a treasure cache of prog rock pleasures, with the musical prowess of one of the genre's most endearing and timeless bands backing it up.

DonaldFRobertson ,

Amazing Music Writing and Musicianship

I came late to Genesis, but as a musician myself, I too consider this possibly the best rock album of all time. Why? In my opinion, the sheer compositional skill demonstrated in this album is unprecedented outside of the classical world. The musicianship, too, is stunning (at least in a studio setting; the live recordings are not as good). Don’t use it as background music: it deserves your full attention. The musicians make one of the hardest of musical skills sound easy: coming down off a dramatic high to a quiet and slow passage without losing the sense of drive and excitement. But it is the writing that makes this album unique. The chord progressions are simple but uniformly effective and beautiful, as are the dramatic key and tempo changes. These folks know their music theory, and deploy it well. It sounds absurd, but in some ways this music reminds me of a Beethoven symphony in that we’ll be firmly ensconced in a beautiful melody, and suddenly out of nowhere, with no obvious logic or connection, we’re in an apparently unrelated melody that is perfectly connected to the first one. Highly, highly recommended.

(The best pieces – in my opinion – are “The Cinema Show,” “Firth of Fifth” with it’s simple but effective piano and flute solos and hauntingly beautiful guitar solo, and “Dancing with the Moonlit Knight,” in that order.)

More By Genesis

You May Also Like