17 Songs, 33 Minutes

EDITORS’ NOTES

Trying to explain Robert Pollard's appeal to someone not in his cult can either make sense to the potential new fan or simply result in more questions. It's rare for a record by an acclaimed songwriter to include three great songs that only clock in at 50 seconds ("Suit Minus the Middle"), 43 seconds ("I Have to Drink"), and one minute and 52 seconds (the R.E.M. dead ringer "I Killed a Man Who Looks Like You"), but that's what we get on Honey Locust Honky Tonk. Only on an album like this can a two-and-a-half-minute opener ("He Requested Things") and a three-plus-minute closer ("Airs") feel a bit overcooked. For those already in the know, Robert Pollard has released far too much music to surprise; anyone who's spent time with his band Guided by Voices is familiar with the sounds he prefers. Due to the brevity of Honey Locust Honky Tonk—17 songs in 34 minutes—it's worthy for both the fan who must have everything and for the newbie who must decide if this Pollard gentleman is someone worth knowing better. It's all here.

EDITORS’ NOTES

Trying to explain Robert Pollard's appeal to someone not in his cult can either make sense to the potential new fan or simply result in more questions. It's rare for a record by an acclaimed songwriter to include three great songs that only clock in at 50 seconds ("Suit Minus the Middle"), 43 seconds ("I Have to Drink"), and one minute and 52 seconds (the R.E.M. dead ringer "I Killed a Man Who Looks Like You"), but that's what we get on Honey Locust Honky Tonk. Only on an album like this can a two-and-a-half-minute opener ("He Requested Things") and a three-plus-minute closer ("Airs") feel a bit overcooked. For those already in the know, Robert Pollard has released far too much music to surprise; anyone who's spent time with his band Guided by Voices is familiar with the sounds he prefers. Due to the brevity of Honey Locust Honky Tonk—17 songs in 34 minutes—it's worthy for both the fan who must have everything and for the newbie who must decide if this Pollard gentleman is someone worth knowing better. It's all here.

TITLE TIME

Ratings and Reviews

4.1 out of 5
16 Ratings

16 Ratings

Rockfan88 ,

Honey Locust Honky Tonk

The album is very good and all the songs are very enjoyable. One problem songs are too short. I would of given this album 5 stars if the songs that were a minute or just over 2 minutes longer were just a minute longer than i would of given the album 5 stars. (sigh) Oh well Robert Pollard still gave us a very good album to listen to.

Eris523 ,

She hides in black

This record pretty much rules. My advice is for you to do yourself a favor and check it out pronto. Do you know what time it's dangerously close to? The time when your mind is blown by this record. 5 stars. I'm out.

More By Robert Pollard

You May Also Like