16 Songs, 48 Minutes

EDITORS’ NOTES

The singular phrasing and manic yowls of Isaac Brock are here in abundance, as are turn-on-a-dime melodies, compelling lyrics, and inventive rhythms. But Good News also expands on the skeletal urgency of earlier albums to include slurring, stomping horns (supplied by the Dirty Dozen Brass Band), banjo, violin, and keyboards. It all comes together as an imaginative masterpiece by a rock band with wild-hearted vision.

Parental Advisory: Explicit Lyrics.

EDITORS’ NOTES

The singular phrasing and manic yowls of Isaac Brock are here in abundance, as are turn-on-a-dime melodies, compelling lyrics, and inventive rhythms. But Good News also expands on the skeletal urgency of earlier albums to include slurring, stomping horns (supplied by the Dirty Dozen Brass Band), banjo, violin, and keyboards. It all comes together as an imaginative masterpiece by a rock band with wild-hearted vision.

Parental Advisory: Explicit Lyrics.
TITLE TIME

Ratings and Reviews

4.6 out of 5
911 Ratings

911 Ratings

CPShelley ,

Don't listen to your scene friends!

Nothing is more frustrating than to see someone so caught up in the "Alternative Scene" that they ignore "The Mainstream Album(s)" of a particular band. Completely disregarding the record before the sound waves reach their ears for the sheer fact that one or two songs made it to the radio. Big deal! This album is brilliant. I personally find it far more evolved than that of "The Moon and Antarctica;" which is a blasphemous statement to some in the Modest Mouse fanatic variety. Lyrically, this is the pinnacle of Modest Mouse's music. With tracks such as "Bury Me With It," "Satin in a Coffin," and "This Devil's Workday," they have proven that the term "genre" has little bearing on their sound. Absolutely worth your money!

jdkn72 ,

Beyond "Float On"

Only the bandwagon Modest Mouse fan says that Float On is as good as it gets. Quite frankly, I like this album just as much as their old ones. Yes, it's a different sound, but they'll still a hell of a band.

rsmith3813 ,

A "How To" on Polarizing a Fanbase

Prior to 'Good News', Modest Mouse was one of those Indie bands that were praised for their music, but received little attention in the mainstream modern rock world. 'The Moon & Antarctica' and 'The Lonesome Crowded West' are filled with Isaac Brock's sarcastic, ingenious humor, but it was apparently a little too difficult to digest for the music industry.

Then 'Good News' was released. "Float On" became a hit single, and Modest Mouse was the surprise hit of 2004. All of a sudden Modest Mouse's earlier albums were selling as fast as 'Good News', and, like it or not, the band's popularity spiked.

Now, this divided Modest Mouse's loyal fanbase; could it be considered "selling out"? Many certainly thought this was the case; it seemed like every radio station was playing "Float On", and as a result, many dejected Modest Mouse's material.

Unfortunately for them, 'Good News' is a brilliant album. The quality of Brock's songwriting certainly hasn't declined; in fact, it seems to have improved over the course of Modest Mouse's life. The album's strongest points lie just outside of the single "Float On", though.

"Bukowski" and "This Devil's Workday" provide a snarky, mischievous, sarcastic outlook on life that the band has been recording since 'This is a Long Drive for Someone with Nothing to Think About', while "Bury Me With It" provides a darker, heavier sound that is unlike anything else Modest Mouse has ever produced. Other highlights include "The View", a poppy, synth-fueled song lined with lyrics that contrast the mood of the song, the airy "World At Large" and "Ocean Breathes Salty", and the driving folk-influenced "Satin In a Coffin" reminiscent of 'The Lonesome Crowded West'.

Long story short, don't be blindsighted by the success of this album; it's an essential member of the unusual, complex, somewhat dysfunctional family of Modest Mouse's albums and rarities, and, in fact, may be one of the most important to their career, both professionally and musically.

More By Modest Mouse

You May Also Like