- Bernstein: West Side Story - Highlights · 1985
- Bernstein: West Side Story · 1985
- Bernstein: West Side Story · 1985
- Bernstein: West Side Story - Highlights · 1985
- Man of La Mancha (New Broadway Cast Recording (2002)) · 1990
- Passion (2013 New York Cast Recording) · 2013
- Chip Deffaa's Rare and Unrecorded Irving Berlin Songs · 2024
- Other Lives (Original Off Broadway Cast) · 2023
- Chip Deffaa's the George M. Cohan Songbook · 2022
- Chip Deffaa's Irving Berlin: Love Songs and Such · 2021
- Chip Deffaa's the Irving Berlin Duets Album, Vol. One · 2019
- Chip Deffaa's Gay Love · 2018
- Chip Deffaa's Irving Berlin Rediscovered: Rare Songs of Love and Longing · 2017